We don’t need to agree on Israel/Palestine to work well together.


In my last newsletter, I highlighted the extreme polarization between certain factions of Zionist and anti-Zionist Jews on college campuses. The examples were intense. Each side literally thought the other side was trying to kill them.

We see this polarization in the Jewish community outside of college campuses as well. On the extreme ends of the debate, one side thinks Israel can do no wrong, and the other side thinks Israel is a scourge on the Jewish people and the world at large.

I’d venture to say that most of us fall between these poles. I certainly do. But we don’t need to fall in the same place on the Israel/Palestine Opinion Spectrum (™) to be a good match for college counseling.

Wherever you stand, and wherever your teen stands, my job is to listen and understand. We have a diversity of viewpoints and opinions within the Jewish community, and I am eager to get to know your student and see what they think and how they feel about this stuff. What they need and want from their college experience will follow from there.

In addition to the spectrum of opinions, there is a spectrum of intensity. Some Jewish students feel strongly about Israel/Palestine and how it will affect their college experience, and for other Jewish students, it is low on their list of priorities.

Wherever your student stands, and however intense their feelings are, I am ready to listen.

113 Cherry St #92768, Seattle, WA, 98104-2205
Unsubscribe · Preferences

Purple Goat College Consulting

Hi! I'm Rachel Oshinsky. I help students and families with the college process, and I particularly love working with LGBTQIA+ and Jewish folks. If you are looking for insights into the college process and beyond from an LGBTQIA+ and Jewish perspective, welcome!

Read more from Purple Goat College Consulting

Hello, friends. I hope you are well. I am checking in on the eve of Yom Kippur with a heavy heart and an upset stomach. The ongoing, seemingly never-ending war in Gaza is making me want to throw up. Earlier in the war, I attended events at my synagogue to discuss it, but I have stopped. They held a discussion about Zohran Mamdani, and I didn’t attend that either because the major headline about Mamdani is where he stands on Israel. I wish we had more space to talk about other things. I had...

Bend the Arc is a US-based progressive Jewish organization with an interesting take on antisemitism. I would recommend their Dismantling Antisemitism Message Guide for its refreshing perspective that challenges popular notions of antisemitism, but I’m not going to make you open another window. I’ll just summarize. Basically, they teach that antisemitism is manmade and therefore can be man-destroyed. They teach that we can end antisemitism, and they criticize folks who talk about antisemitism...

I’ve been trying to wrap my head around the devastating acts of violence against American Jews in Boulder and DC. I’m sure you have too. The Boulder attack was an act of cruelty in which the assailant set demonstrators, including the elderly, on fire. In DC it was an act of murder. These were targeted attacks against Jews. People are furious at Israel for its destruction in Gaza, and this is reasonable. I am too. But being furious at Israel doesn’t cause a reasonable person to wield a Molotov...